Introduction to Scotland's Rent Regulation

Scotland's rent regulation landscape is undergoing significant changes with the expiration of temporary rent adjudication measures on March 31, 2025. These measures, part of the Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Act 2022 and later extended by the Rent Adjudication (Temporary Modifications) (Scotland) Regulations 2024, aimed to protect tenants from sudden rent hikes during the cost-of-living crisis. The end of these measures brings both opportunities and challenges for tenants and landlords alike.

Background on Temporary Measures

The temporary measures introduced in 2022 were designed as a response to rising inflation and the need to stabilize household expenses. They included a rent cap of up to 12% and allowed tenants to challenge rent increases through a rent adjudication process managed by Rent Service Scotland (RSS). This system used a taper formula to ensure rents were reasonable and aligned with local market rates. The measures were extended into 2024 but are now coming to an end.

What Changes Are Happening?

As of April 1, 2025, several key changes will affect both tenants and landlords:

• Removal of Rent Caps: The maximum cap on rent increases will no longer apply. Landlords can propose rent increases without an upper limit, although these must still be assessed by RSS if challenged by tenants.
• Open Market Assessments: RSS will determine rent levels based on open market rates. This means rents could be set higher than landlords' initial proposals if the market supports it.
• Challenge Process Remains: Tenants still have 21 days to challenge proposed rent increases. However, the challenge is riskier now as the final rent could be higher than proposed.
• Notice Requirements: Landlords must provide three months' notice for rent increases, and these can only be implemented once in a 12-month period for tenancies starting after December 1, 2017.

Key Points for Tenants and Landlords:

• Rent Increases: One increase per year for applicable tenancies, with exceptions.
• Notice Period: Three months' notice required for rent increases.
• Challenge Process: Tenants have 21 days to challenge proposed increases.
• Appeals: Both tenants and landlords have appeal options through the First-tier Tribunal.

Concerns and Implications

The end of these measures has raised concerns about potential rent spikes as landlords seek to recover costs accumulated during the period of capped increases. Propertymark and other industry voices have warned that restrictive rent controls can lead to long-term increases in rents and discourage investment in the rental market.

Long-term Proposals: The Housing (Scotland) Bill

While the immediate focus is on the cessation of temporary measures, the Housing (Scotland) Bill proposes longer-term rent control solutions. This bill is in the amendment stage and aims to establish a system where local authorities assess rent levels to determine areas for rent control caps. If passed, rent increases in designated areas could be limited to CPI plus 1% (capped at 6%). However, this legislation is not expected to come into effect until 2027.

Future of Rent Regulation in Scotland

The current environment presents challenges for policymakers, who must balance tenant protection with the need to maintain a healthy and attractive rental market for investors. The lessons learned from the temporary measures will be crucial in shaping future policies.

What Tenants Can Do

1. Monitor Local Rentals: Track market rates to prepare for potential challenges.
2. Negotiate with Landlords: Attempt to reach agreements on rent increases.
3. Document Property Issues: Highlight any outstanding repairs when challenging rent increases.

Impact on Landlords

1. Recovery of Costs: Opportunity to recoup losses from periods of capped rents.
2. Market Rate Alignments: Rents can now be set based on current market conditions.

As Scotland transitions back to standard rent adjudication rules, it will be crucial for both tenants and landlords to understand their rights and responsibilities within this new framework. The coming months will provide clarity on whether these changes lead to a more sustainable rental environment or if they exacerbate existing issues.

---