"Beyond Rhetoric: Collective Action Over Dosti in Politics—P Chidambaram's Vision for India"

In his insightful column "Across the Aisle," former Indian Finance Minister P Chidambaram continues to offer thought-provoking analyses of India's political landscape and economic trajectory. Mr. Chidambaram's writings not only reflect deep political acumen but also underscore the need for collective action in India's development journey, especially when juxtaposed with the concept of "dosti" or friendship in politics. This article delves into the nuances of Chidambaram's vision for India and explores how collaborative governance can be more effective than mere political camaraderie.

---

Introduction to P Chidambaram's "Across the Aisle"

P Chidambaram's "Across the Aisle" has been a significant voice in Indian political discourse, offering critiques and proposals on various governance and economic fronts. His writing often touches upon critical issues, ranging from macroeconomic policies to social and economic inclusion, which are central to creating a more equitable society in India.

The Concept of Collective Action

Collective action in politics refers to the coordinated efforts of different stakeholders to achieve common objectives. This can be much more powerful than reliance on individual friendships or "dosti" in politics because it fosters a broader coalition and ensures sustainable progress. In India's context, collective action could involve the government, opposition parties, civil society, and the private sector coming together to address pressing issues like economic inequality, climate change, and social justice.

---

Why Collective Action Matters Over "Dosti" in Politics

While "dosti" or friendship in politics can facilitate dialogues and short-term collaborations, it often remains limited in scope and can be influenced by personal interests rather than the greater good. Collective action, on the other hand, fosters a more inclusive and sustainable approach to solving complex problems. Here are some reasons why collective action is more effective:

• Inclusivity: Collective action involves a broader range of stakeholders, ensuring that diverse perspectives are considered and that solutions are more holistic.
• Sustainability: Decisions made through collective action tend to be more durable as they enjoy wider support and involvement from various sectors.
• Accountability: Collective efforts promote shared responsibility, making it easier to hold individuals accountable for their roles in implementing policies or projects.

---

Challenges in Achieving Collective Action in India

Despite its potential benefits, achieving collective action in India faces several challenges:

Political Polarization

One of the major obstacles to collective action is the increasing political polarization in India. This polarization often leads to a lack of trust between parties, making it difficult to build consensus on critical issues.

• Ideological Differences: Different political parties have strong ideological commitments that can lead to disagreements.
• Competitive Politics: The nature of competitive politics in India often prioritizes electoral gains over collaborative governance.

Socioeconomic Inequalities

India is characterized by significant socioeconomic inequalities, which can hinder collective action by creating power imbalances and conflicting interests among stakeholders.

• Economic Disparities: Wealth and opportunity gaps lead to varying levels of influence and representation for different socioeconomic groups.
• Social Inequities: Issues like caste, gender, and religious divisions can complicate coalition-building efforts.

Efforts to Foster Collective Action

Despite these challenges, there are ongoing efforts to foster more collective and inclusive governance practices in India:

• Civil Society Engagement: Organizations are increasingly involved in policy discussions and advocacy, pushing for more participatory governance.
• Cross-Party Dialogues: Initiatives like the "Across the Aisle" column encourage dialogue beyond party lines to address common goals.

---

P Chidambaram's Vision for Viksit Bharat (Developed India)

In recent writings, P Chidambaram has highlighted the importance of macroeconomic stability and social inclusion as key pillars for achieving a Viksit Bharat by 2047. His emphasis on macroeconomic focus on growth includes maintaining fiscal discipline, managing inflation, and ensuring stable interest rates. However, he also critiques the current government's approach to these goals, citing issues like a high fiscal deficit and rising economic inequalities.

Four Pillars for Viksit Bharat

1. Macro-economic Focus on Growth: This involves maintaining a balance in fiscal policies, keeping inflation in check, and ensuring stable interest rates.
2. Social and Economic Inclusion: Policies should aim to reduce economic disparities and promote equal opportunities for all.
3. Ethical Wealth Creation: Encouraging ethical business practices to ensure wealth creation benefits society as a whole.
4. Virtuous Cycle of Private Investment: Encouraging private investment to drive economic growth and create jobs.

---

Conclusion: Moving Towards Collective Action

In conclusion, while "dosti" in politics can provide temporary benefits, collective action remains the most effective strategy for achieving sustainable progress in India. By leveraging the insights from "Across the Aisle" and focusing on inclusive governance practices, India can move closer to becoming a Viksit Bharat. This vision for India's future requires not just economic growth but also social harmony and political stability—goals that can be better achieved through collective action rather than reliance on individual friendships.

Key Takeaways for Policy Makers and Citizens

• Emphasize Collective Action: Prioritize inclusive, multi-stakeholder approaches over personal relationships in political decision-making.
• Address Socioeconomic Inequalities: Implement policies that reduce economic disparities and foster equal opportunities.
• Promote Cross-Party Dialogues: Encourage discussions across party lines to build consensus and achieve broader support for policies.

By adopting these strategies, India can overcome the challenges of political polarization and socioeconomic divisions, moving towards a more collaborative and equitable political landscape.